I work with children diagnosed with autism. They are very sensitive to sounds and will be upset by the sound of the traditional tagger (clicker).
I work with people who are hard of hearing. They won't be able to hear the click sound.
I teach riding to children and adults and all my horses are clicker trained, so I don't want to use the same sound for the people since the horses might get upset or confused if the hear the click sounds and don't get a treat.
I teach people to clicker train dogs (or other animals) and I am worried that the animals will be confused if I use the same sound for them as for the people.
I would like to try peer tagging, but with so many taggers going off all over the place I don't think anyone will know which tag is for them.Let me preface this discussion by saying that in all the many years and many applications in which the TAGteach founders have used TAGteach, we rarely use anything other than the traditional box clicker (tagger) to make the tag sound. We have tried other things, but in the end they break, we lose them, or they didn't work any better anyway. Even with children diagnosed with autism, noisy roomfuls of kids tagging each other and in the presence of clicker trained animals, we have had great success with the box clicker - as have others.
In trying to decide the best way to deliver the tag stimulus, a TAGteacher needs to consider the following:
- Can the learners perceive the tag?
- Does the learner like to get a tag?
- Is the tag distracting other learners (including animals)?
Does the Learner Perceive the Tag?
We have often been astounded that learners hear their own tag even if there are lots of other taggers and other noise going on. If they don't hear their own tags, then you might need to spread out more, change the position of the person with the tagger so they are closer to or within the line of sight of the learner or take turns with tagging so that fewer taggers are going off at once. You will most likely find that once the learners become tag savvy, they don't have any trouble hearing the tag that is meant for them.
Does the Learner Like the Sound of the Tag
Some learners find the tag sound aversive. This is more often true with adults than kids. They may dislike the sound for no particular reason, may experience physical pain (very rare) or may have a past negative association with the sound. Generally they will not suffer in silence and will be quick to let you know that you are causing them grave suffering. Sometimes this aversion can be remedied by associating the tag sound with a tangible reinforcer (candy, stickers, chocolate etc). Sometimes they get over it when they see others progressing well and the want to have some of that success for themselves. The tag sound has not been a problem for professionals working with children diagnosed with autism. These children seem to adapt well to the tag sound, most likely because it is associated with a primary reinforcer (popcorn, a sip of soda etc) and because they quickly learn that this is the sound of success and something that they can control in an otherwise largely uncontrollable world. This latter is just speculation, since we haven't conducted any studies, but it has been a surprise to some to find that sound-sensitive children are not bothered by the sound of the tagger.
Read our blog posts about TAGteach and autism
Visit our autism web page for scientific research reports
Is the Tag Distracting Other Learners?
The tag sound is generally not distracting to other learners who are also engaged in the tag session. For example a roomful of gymnasts or volleyball players all tagging in pairs or groups will not disrupt the others. They get very good, very quickly at concentrating and hearing the tag that is meant for them. In a quiet situation in which a teacher is tagging one student for reading skills, while the others work quietly, the tag sound could be distracting.
Many people are using TAGteach to teach animal-handling skills. In the majority of these cases the animals are clicker trained, or are being clicker trained and so the tag for the person could be distracting for the animal. Some people are concerned that the power of the click will be diminished if the animal hears a lot of clicking and doesn't get a treat.. People who teach group clicker training classes, train animals in a group situation or have multiple clicker trained animals at home know that animals very quickly learn that not every click is for them and not every clicker session involves them. They learn to read environmental cues, pay attention to where the trainer's cues are directed and most importantly to where the treats are coming from and where they are going. Animals become very good at knowing when it is their turn.
When animals are first learning about clicker training, or if the animal is likely to get excited and become a danger, then an alternative approach is needed. This may involve using a different sound or working on the human skills with the animal out of the picture at first. In some cases it may be appropriate to have the click and the tag be the same. For example, if you are teaching loose leash walking and the tag point is "leash hand at waist", then both dog and person could get a click/tag at the same time. If the use of TAGteach for teaching animal handling skills becomes confusing and problematic, then you need to take steps to simplify.
If you are tagging to tell the person that they clicked properly, you can have the person pretend to click (just do the click movement without having a clicker). If you see them do the virtual click at the right time, then you actually click too. This click will be the tag for the person and the click for the dog. This way the dog only gets clicked at the right time while the person is learning and only one actual click/tag happens. Once the person has the timing right they can take over the real clicker.
But I Need an Alternative Signal!
Sometimes you really may need an alternative signal for the tag, whether it be a different sound or a different signal altogether. Here are some alternatives to the traditional box clicker (tagger) that have been used or suggested by TAGteachers:
- i-click (quieter click sound)
- Clicker+ (makes 4 different sounds - these are no longer in production)
- Muffle the sound of a box clicker with a cloth, your hand or from inside a pocket
- Car key fob (from the dollar store - makes the sound that your remote car door opener makes when you unlock your car)
- Squeaker from squeaky toy
- Clap hands
- Click from ball point pen
- Click from hand-held counter (also counts the tags, which can be useful)
- Juice bottle lids that pop when pressed
- Bicycle bell
- Party noisemaker
- Ding from triangle instrument
- Flash of light
- Tap of finger on shoulder or hand
- Hold tagger against the learner's back so the feel it, if they can't hear it
- Virtual tag - pretend to tag by making the tag motion without tagger
- Slide a ticket or a block or other marker from one side of the desk to the other
- Pull down a bead on a tagulator
Here is a video that shows a shoulder tap being used as a tag:
If you want to buy tagulators or taggers (i-clicks or box clickers) you can get them at the TAGteach store.